| Author |
Topic: Mafia C9 Series Game 2A |
225 replies
|
|
|
I had Franco pegged as scum as soon as Michael flipped scum, although I couldnt be totally certain. Joseph was clearly town so it became a coin flip for him.
Joseph, would you have voted differently if Jun had said he had investigated Franco instead of you. IF I had been cop in that situation, I may have been tempted to lie about the investigation result, and instead said I investigated the guilty one instead of the actual innocent result.
|
|
|
|
|
Quote ( Gordon Ashford @ February 15th 2010,20:02:27 )
Joseph, would you have voted differently if Jun had said he had investigated Franco instead of you. IF I had been cop in that situation, I may have been tempted to lie about the investigation result, and instead said I investigated the guilty one instead of the actual innocent result.
Probably, but I think he did the right thing investigating me as I could have just lynched my buddy to make me look better, he should of investigated me then told me that he investigated Franco ;)
|
|
|
|
|
Quote ( Gordon Ashford @ February 15th 2010,20:02:27 )
I had Franco pegged as scum as soon as Michael flipped scum
You should of said something before with your vote to tell me your opinion, it probably would have moved my vote because I trus you more then I trust myself in mafia games. ;)
|
|
|
|
|
Quote ( Joseph Wood @ February 15th 2010,20:07:37 )
You should of said something before with your vote to tell me your opinion, it probably would have moved my vote because I trus you more then I trust myself in mafia games. ;)
Maybe it had something to do with me being dead then.
I only worked out it was probably Franco after Michael was lynched.
|
|
|
|
|
Quote ( Gordon Ashford @ February 15th 2010,20:12:14 )
I only worked out it was probably Franco after Michael was lynched.
Oh ok
|
|
|
|
|
Quote ( Gordon Ashford @ February 15th 2010,20:02:27 )
I had Franco pegged as scum as soon as Michael flipped scum, although I couldnt be totally certain. Joseph was clearly town so it became a coin flip for him.
No way i was keeping you alive :) It's really hard to play against you Gordon.
Quote ( Joseph Wood @ February 15th 2010,19:58:23 )
Sorry everyone :(
Well, i guess in this situation is very hard to decide, i was very impatient too for the game to end, no matter the result :)
|
|
|
|
|
Oh MAN! Lol sorry if my play was a bit weird...... learning from this game! Well done Franco, but you cant win with just one person :P
|
|
|
|
|
Quote ( Tomasz Wypych @ February 15th 2010,20:00:39 )
MVP obviously (as it is for the member of the winning side) goes to Franco.
I disagree, MVP was Jun for the scum. He should have claimed on day 2 when the game was in "lylo". Making himself instead of Gordon the NK target. Either way I think scum would have been sunk real fast on a day 2 cop claim. Franco was all over someone Jun knew to be town from his N1 investigation, so if he threw that out there on day 2.. I think Franco would have been lynched, with a REAL fast day 3 following for the town victory.
|
|
|
|
|
I never knew I could claim anything..... I thought something like this isnt allowed to be said on a forum, until Tomasz kindly PMed me.... :P
|
|
|
|
You cannot directly quote your role pm. You could say you are the cop, the doctor, the schoolbus driver, the mason, or anything else really. So long as you do not directly quote your role that is pm'd to you. It would have changed the game completely if two things happend. The second was your claiming on the second day. Of course it may well have been perceived by everyone else to be a faked claim, so who knows what would have happend. Speaking of who knows what would have happened that leads me to the other game changer.
The first was if Gordon left the first day lynch to a coinflip. At least he would have had a 50% chance of getting a scum instead of the 0% chance he had with leaving it on Rusty at the end.
As you see, this is a learning experience. Jun I hoped you learned a little something from this.
|
|
|
|
|
Quote ( Frank Rizzo @ February 15th 2010,20:53:01 )
The first was if Gordon left the first day lynch to a coinflip. At least he would have had a 50% chance of getting a scum instead of the 0% chance he had with leaving it on Rusty at the end.
Hindsight is great though, and I thought that Rusty was a decent bet for the lynch, and in all truth, didnt have Franco anywhere near the top of my scum list, my vote was only there to see if anyone jumped online and voted.
|
|
|
|
|
Actually you jumped your vote on BOTH of the scums before placing it back on Rusty.
|
|
|
|
|
Quote ( Frank Rizzo @ February 15th 2010,21:14:46 )
Actually you jumped your vote on BOTH of the scums before placing it back on Rusty.
yeah, thanks for bringing that up :(
|
|
|
|
Can't resist anymore
##Vote Gordon
Never trust him guys. :P
|
|
|
|
|
Yeah.... well I thank Tomasz for giving me a chance to play in this game :P Learnt a lot from here :P
|
|
|
|
Bah, instantly thought Gordon was scum the second I was nk'ed. :(
Also, sorry for going a little (lot) inactive at the end of day 1, I went down to Melbourne for the weekend and couldn't make it on the internet.
|
|
